You'll get no argument on that account.
Domain evaluations are often silly. The only way to price one is by determing what someone is willing to pay in the open market, which is to say, put it up for sale and attract as many potential buyers as possible. If the website content is included in the sale of a domain then you have to add the value of the site content and any associated revenue stream.
judging by the only thing on that site, it doesn't look like it. Snopes says that it is worth a whopping $540 bucks, and I guess that is based on age of name, but that would probably be accurate only if it was actually used during the last 10 years whomever owned it.Saw an article recently about someone thinking of selling 30A.com...did it ever sell?

